WLS Radio Show 2025-11-23 E201

Treasures in the Trash? Plus, Razor Blades, Ragtime, and $90k Amps

Fresh off the heels of a record-breaking "Cowboys and Indians" event, the energy in the studio is electric this week! If you think the auction action slows down for the holidays, think again. In this episode of the Donley Auctions Hour, Susan, Mike, and Randy dive into a packed December calendar perfect for unique gift-giving. They share incredible stories of "junk" turning into jackpots and put out a massive call for 2026 consignments. From WWI history to barn-find Mustangs, you won't want to miss these stories.

Show Highlights

Auction Recap

The team buzzes about the massive turnout for the "Cowboys and Indians" auction. They note that while the collector demographic is aging, the market and museum interest remain incredibly strong.

Dec 4 Auction – Razor Blade Advertising

A preview of a unique 196-lot auction featuring Art Deco displays and barber shop memorabilia is on the horizon. This auction promises to be a visual treat for collectors.

WWI History Lesson

Randy shares a fascinating tidbit about why Gillette sold 3.5 million shaving kits to the army. Soldiers had to be clean-shaven for gas masks to seal properly! This historical insight adds depth to the auction items.

Hidden Value

A reminder never to judge a book by its cover—literally. A Michael Jordan rookie card was recently found tucked inside a book of sports cards. It is now off for grading, showcasing the hidden treasures that can be found in unexpected places.

Global Treasure Hunting

Randy recaps his recent trip to Tampa, where he evaluated a massive music machine collection, including Nickelodeons and phonographs. He also teases upcoming trips to Indiana, Tennessee, and Colorado, promising more discoveries.

Dec 11 Auction – "Collector's Dream"

This event is perfect for holiday shoppers. It features everything from fossils and furniture to toys and advertising. There’s something for everyone at this auction.

Star Lot Spotlight

A rare 1905 Wing & Sons 5-pedal upright grand piano takes the spotlight. It produces a unique "honky-tonk" sound, has no reserve, and starts at just $100! This is a must-see for music enthusiasts.

Dec 13 Auction – Firearms & Ammo

The complexities of Illinois gun laws are discussed. Donley’s FFL license helps families legally and safely liquidate inherited collections. This is crucial information for potential sellers.

"Don't Throw It Away!"

Two cautionary tales about cleaning house before an appraisal are shared:

• A small oil can found on a staircase, destined for the trash, sold for $1,500.

• A "cheap" fruit bowl in a kitchen turned out to be rare Teco pottery that sold for $5,000.

  
  

These stories emphasize the importance of careful evaluation before discarding items.

Wanted: Movie Memorabilia

Mike is on the hunt for theater artifacts. He shares a legendary story of a Western Electric amplifier rack found on a porch that the owner almost scrapped. It sold for over $90,000! This highlights the potential value of overlooked items.

Wanted: License Plates

A call for pre-1960 plates, especially porcelain and #1s, is made. There’s also a shout-out for rare Tucker automobile manufacturer plates. Collectors should take note!

Barn Find Legends

The team swaps stories about pulling vehicles from the brink:

• The "Hoarder House" auction where they cut through walls to find a buried ’65 Mustang.

• A 1911 Hupmobile stored since 1938 that tripled the owner's private offer.

• A 1959 Cadillac brought up from Florida that shocked experts by hammering at $110,000.

  
  

These barn find legends showcase the thrill of discovery in the auction world.

The "Weird" Wishlist

The show wraps with a call for the obscure, including vintage tanks, cannons, and a specific request for a barn-find biplane! This eclectic wishlist reflects the diverse interests of collectors.

Listen to the full episode here: https://youtu.be/gtN2n7Xd_RU